Top 10 Best Benefit Eyeliner Reviews & Comparison

It can be hard to know what the best benefit eyeliner is when you’re trying to make a purchase. With so many products on the market, all with different features and benefits, how can you know which one is right for you?

Luckily, there are ways to figure it out. One way is by reading reviews. Reviews can give you a good idea of what people liked and didn’t like about a benefit eyeliner and whether it’s worth purchasing.

Another way to find the best benefit eyeliner is by looking at lists of the best products. Lists like this one, compiled after analyzing 57253 reviews from real people just like you.

Here, we’ve put together a list of the top 10 best benefit eyeliner in different categories to help you make an informed decision. So read on to discover our top picks and find the perfect benefit eyeliner for your needs!

Top Best Benefit Eyeliner On The Market 2023

Bestseller No. 1
Benefit Roller Liner True Matte Liquid Eyeliner
  • Benefit Roller Liner True Matte Liquid Eyeliner
SaleBestseller No. 2
Benefit They're Real Xtreme Precision waterproof liquid eyeliner 0.35 mL / 0.01 US fl. oz. (Black)
  • Precision, major versatility! Glide on sleek, ultra-pigmented lines with this waterproof liquid eyeliner featuring a custom 0.1mm tapered brush tip made for comfort & precision.
  • The brush tip is made of a blend of ultra-fine, firm-yet-flexible bristles for smooth, clean application to create precisely the look you want.
  • Waterproof Smudge-proof Flake-free Feels weightless Quick-set formula Buildable Satin finish
  • Benefit They're Real Xtreme Precision waterproof liquid eyeliner 0.35 mL / 0.01 US fl. oz.
  • Shake well. Apply along lash line. Layer for a more dramatic line. From pin-thin definition to bold drama and everything in between...get it ALL lined up!
SaleBestseller No. 3
KIKO Milano Lasting Precision Automatic Eyeliner And Khôl 15 | Automatic eye pencil for the waterline and lash line
  • Automatic eye pencil for the waterline and lash line
  • It delivers a precise, even and long-lasting stroke
  • The deep colour is revealed instantly
  • The soft texture glides on and may be blended using the pencil’s built-in applicator
  • Ophthalmologically tested, water resistant.
Bestseller No. 4
Stila All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, Easy To Use Eyeliner Pen, Smudge and Transfer Proof, Liner Stays On All Day and Night, Goes On Smoothly Without Skipping, Smudging or Pulling
  • Your Go-To Liquid Eyeliner: An easy-application, waterproof liquid liner that stays on all day and night. You can always count on this easy-glide, quick-dry precision liner to stay in place.
  • Achieve Whatever Look You Want: By using the Stay All Day Waterproof Eyeliner, you can achieve any look you can think of! Produce seamless wings and precise details in an instant.
  • Easy To Use Eyeliner Pen: This eyeliner pen features a felt tip applicator for easy, precise application. Create thick or thin lines without skipping, or pulling.
  • Intense Pigment Slides On With Ease: Get the dramatic effect you’re looking for with this waterproof eye liner that goes on smoothly and doesn’t smudge, transfer, or run.
  • Our Commitment To You: Stila is committed to providing women worldwide with the highest quality and safest beauty products.
Bestseller No. 5
NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Eye Liner, Felt Tip Liner Pen, Waterproof, Vegan Formula, Black
  • Highly pigmented waterproof eyeliner pen with felt tip applicator, Ideal for long nights out
  • Get the classic bold winged eye, Achieve fine and natural or broad and bold strokes
  • Slender and supple brush tip for precise application, Draw thin or thick lines by varying the pressure and angling of the brush
  • Highly pigmented and waterproof for rich, longwearing colour, Smooth and effortless application, Vegan formula
  • Contents: 1 x NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner, Black
Bestseller No. 6
Benefit MINI Roller Liner - True Matte Liquid Eyeliner - Black 0.5ml
  • Using the side of the pen, stamp along lash line to map out the direction of your liner
  • Start your Wing from the outer corner of your eye and bring it in toward the inner corner
  • Connect the lines and refine to get your perfect look
  • Item weight: 0.01 pounds
  • the quick-dry, waterproof formula lasts 24 hours and dries to a natural-matte finish
Bestseller No. 7
Benefit Roller Liner (1ml, Brown)
  • Glide on a natural-looking, fine line with Roller Liner! Our matte liquid eyeliner features a precision felt tip for sharp controlled lines and a super-smooth application that wont drag or jag. The quick-dry, waterproof formula lasts 24-hours. It doesnt fade, flake or smudge so you can let the good times roll all day & night!
  • A true-matte liquid eyeliner that glides on smooth and precise linesperfect for creating any look, from a thin line to a dramatic cat eye.A true-matte liquid eyeliner that glides on smooth and precise linesperfect for creating any look, from a thin line to a dramatic cat eye.
  • Roller Liner Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner features an easy-glide, precision, felt tip for sharp, controlled lines and a super-smooth application. The quick-dry, waterproof formula lasts up to 24 hours, and wont fade, flake, bleed, or smudge.
  • 1.0 mL / 0.03 US fl. oz.
Bestseller No. 9
  • Buildable coverage
  • Easy applicator tip
  • Smudgee on one end, liner on the other
  • Long wear
  • Matte finish
SaleBestseller No. 10
Maybelline Hyper Precise All Day Liner Black
  • Exclusive felt tip. Never dries. Never skips.
  • Ultra-thin 0.4mm brush supplies smooth, even lines.
  • Ink technology keeps pigments super-saturated, offering a precise line for lasting intensity.
  • Safe for sensitive eyes and ophthalmologist-tested.
  • x1 Hyper Precise Liquid Eyeliner, Black, Felt tip, 0.63g
SaleBestseller No. 11
Superliner by L'Oreal Paris Perfect Slim Intense Black
  • Highly pigmented eye liner, Ideal for defined lines and a range of looks
  • Intense matte colour that lasts up to 24h, Perfect for winged eyes or eye flick looks
  • Apply the eyeliner pen tip as close to the lash line as possible starting at the inner corner of the eye. Then, draw towards the outer corner of the eye. Apply more pressure for thicker lines.
  • Water-resistant and smudge-proof, Ultra-precise tip for fine lines, Optimum control thanks to its grip zone hold
  • Contents: 1x L'Oreal Paris Perfect Slim Liquid Eyeliner, Superliner, Smudge-proof, Water-resistant, Intense Matte Colour, Brown
Bestseller No. 12
Velvet Eyeliner Pencil by Artisan L'uxe Beauty|Jumbo Eye Pencil for Smokey Eye|Water-Resistant & Smudge Proof|Long-Lasting|Sue Devitt Parent (Black)
  • SMOLDERING EYES: Our Velvet Eye L’uxe Pencil provides a luxuriously smooth and long-lasting effect designed to naturally intensify your eye color and make your eyes smolder. Whatever look you are trying to achieve, the Velvet Eye L’uxe Pencil will help you get there while keeping you looking natural.
  • HIGH PERFORMANCE: Not only does our formulation glide on effortlessly, but it is smudge-proof, long-lasting and water resistant eyeliner. NOTE: This professional-grade eye pencil should be sharpened using our Artisan L’uxe Eye Pencil Sharpener, which is specifically designed to seamlessly sharpen our rich Velvet Eye L’uxe formula, while avoiding unnecessary breakage caused by generic sharpening tools.
  • Our proprietary blend of ingredients works to provide superior cell stimulation to delay the visual signs of aging, offering a fresh, healthy, and youthful radiance inspired by nature's diverse offerings and potency. Meticulously sourced from nature and hand-crafted with artisanal care, our products offer hydration, nourishment, and protection.
  • This chubby eye pencil has a continuous flow and glides on effortlessly, providing smooth and even lines for a professional and easy smokey eye look. Once applied around the eye, the active ingredient ceramides regenerates and firms the delicate eye area. Velvet Eye L’uxe is suitable for eyes of all sensitivity and can be used while wearing contact lenses.
  • ETHICAL & ORGANIC INGREDIENTS: Due to our long-term relationships with local farmers we are able to create an assortment of effective beauty products that delicately merge organic infusions with modern technology to deliver beautifying, protective, and rejuvenating results. We have designed the Velvet Eye L’uxe Pencil with organic infusions of sunflower seed oil, chamomile extract and silk powders that have wonderous benefits on the skin when used.
Bestseller No. 13
KIKO Milano Intense Colour Long Lasting Eyeliner 16 | Intense and smooth-gliding outer eye pencil with long wear
  • Intense, long-wearing outer eye pencil that glides on smoothly
  • The pencil delivers an astounding performance with a melting texture that resembles a liquid eyeliner
  • The special, water-resistant formula stays on for up to 10 hours and is blendable immediately after application
  • The texture melts on contact with the eyelid for a bright and intense line
  • Ophthalmologically tested, dermatologically tested= formulated to ensure minimum instance of allergic reactions
Bestseller No. 14
e.l.f. H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen, Felt Tip, Waterproof Liquid Formula, Jet Black, 0.02 Fl Oz (0.7mL)
  • RICH COLOUR: The e.l.f. H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen enhances the lash line with rich colour.
  • WATERPROOF: This smudge-proof, quick dry liquid eyeliner formula enriched with Vitamin E stays all day.
  • ULTIMATE PRECISION: The felt tip pen applies colour smoothly without smudging, feathering, or running.
  • SKIN-LOVING INGREDIENTS: All e.l.f. products are made from skin-loving ingredients you want, minus the toxins you don’t—all at good-for-you prices. All e.l.f. products are 100% cruelty-free and Vegan.
SaleBestseller No. 15
L'Oreal Paris Superliner Superstar Eyeliner Black
  • Specially designed felt tip
  • Enhances the shape of the eye
  • Flexor system helps you to follow the natural contours
  • Available in black colour shade
  • Please check PAO (Period After Opening) symbol which denotes the product expiry time, post opening the pack
Bestseller No. 16
L'Oréal Paris Gel Eyeliner, Intense Long-lasting Colour, Semi Permanent, Infallible Grip 36H Gel Automatic Eyeliner, Intense Black
  • Semi-permanent long-wear eyeliner available in 4 shades, For intense colour and long-lasting style, Suitable even for sensitive eyes
  • Easy-glide gel formula that lasts all day long, For stunning sharp lines or a smoky, smudged style
  • Create your sharp lines or smudged style using the smudger applicator, Allow to dry, Once dry, your look will be transfer-free for up to 36H
  • Designed using adhesive technologies to encourage pigment grip, Smudge-proof and transfer-proof formula, Sharpener and smudger included
  • Contents: 1x L'Oréal Paris Infallible Grip 36H Gel Automatic Eyeliner, Semi Permanent, With Smudger and Sharpener, Colour: Intense Black
Bestseller No. 17
Boobeen Eyeliner Gel Makeup Black Eye liner Pen Matte Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil Quick Drying Eye liner Gel Stick Eye Makeup Long Lasting
  • Matte Eyeliner: The texture of the eyeliner is smooth and delicate, easy to apply and not easily smudged. Four natural colors easily create a personalized eye makeup.
  • Unique Design: The stylish shape and rotating design allows you to draw directly or use an eyeliner brush dipped in gel. Creating flawless eyeliner wings.
  • Long-lasting Eye Makeup: The eyeliner gel is rich and natural in color, which clearly outlines the eyeliner makeup and brings out the great long-lasting effect. It allows you to keep your delicate eye makeup for a long time.
  • Waterproof and Smudge-proof: This eyeliner has a waterproof and smudge-proof formula with strong adhesion. Keeps you free from makeup removal. The makeup remover removes easily without residue.
  • Easy to Apply: With a eyeliner tip, you can easily control the line to create the desired effect. You can also use a brush dipped in eyeliner gel to apply color and match a variety of looks.
SaleBestseller No. 18
Rimmel Exaggerate Liquid Eyeliner, Black, 2.5ml (Pack of 1)
  • Highly-pigmented liquid formula with a flattering glossy black finish
  • Easy application to create precise lines and vivid looks with just a smooth touch
  • Smudge-proof, flake-proof, smear-proof and run-proof features for long-lasting effect
  • Ideally safe and dermatologically and ophthalmologically tested
  • Waterproof formula for ideal look in changing conditions
Bestseller No. 19
Boobeen 2 Colors Liner Eyeliner Gel Waterproof - Eyebrow Colors Gel Formula Long Lasting - Eye Makeup Set with 2 Pack Eyeliner Brush and Brow Brush
  • 【Practical Makeup Set】The set contains two eyeliners. An angled brush and a thin eyeliner brush. It is suitable for all people who love makeup, whether it is a professional makeup artist or a makeup beginner.
  • 【Smudge-resistant】Thanks to the waterproof formula and safe ingredients, this anti-smudge, waterproof and sweat-proof eyeliner gel set will surely be popular with makeup people. Our products have been tested and can be used with confidence.
  • 【Suitable for all occasions】The practical eyeliner suit is suitable for many occasions, such as Halloween, makeup show, live performance, wedding makeup, dance party, birthday party, casual party, daily life, etc.
  • 【How to use】Before drawing eyeliner, please apply a little eye primer on the eyelid, and then use loose powder to set the makeup. This will make the eye makeup longer. It is not just eyeliner gel, you can also use it as eyebrow gel and eye shadow.
  • 【Best gift】This two-piece eyeliner and eyebrow gel set is a perfect gift for girlfriend, mother, and friends. It is the best gift for others on Christmas, birthday, Thanksgiving and anniversaries.
SaleBestseller No. 20
Winged Eyeliner Stamp-2 Eyeliner Pens for Perfect Wing Cat Eye Stamp Eyeliner Waterproof Smudge Proof, Long Lasting Makeup Liquid Eye Liner (black)
  • A double-ended wing stamp pen - This duo wing stamp pen and felt-tip liquid liner helps create the perfect cat eye all the time. This set is waterproof and smudge-proof that give you all day wear from morning to night. It is so easy for work for a flawless flick just stamp, and line.
  • TikTok Trend Item JUST PERFECT WINGS SO EASY - Do you love a perfect wing but get stressed when doing it? KIMUSE NEW Winged Eyeliner Stamp is literally a dream tool for you. It's not just how easy to use it is either, the tool works SO well!This cuts applying makeup time incredibly complete many looks and touch it up within SECONDS!
  • SMUDGE RESISTANT&WATERPROOF-STAY ALL DAY - The formula is long-lasting, waterproof and smudge-proof. The eye liner liquid pen is well inked and well pigmented. It does not need re-touching throughout the day and evening. All skin available, and we recommend using an eyelid primer for longer wear if you have oily or combination skin.
  • For All Eye Shapes - KIMUSE stamp eyeliner comes with a wing stamp on one end and a fine liner on the other. The eye liner stamps are well inked and well pigmented which makes filling precisely and easily. It makes achieving the perfect cat eye for anyone including with hooded eyes.
  • Gifts for Women - All is love, so let’s share it! KIMUSE Eyeliner Stamp is the perfect gift for all women in your life who love makeup.

How We Tested A Benefit Eyeliner?

When it comes to choosing the best benefit eyeliner for your needs, we want to ensure that the one we select is top quality and reliable. To make sure of this, we put each potential benefit eyeliner through rigorous testing.

First off, we evaluate key performance metrics such as speed, accuracy, and ease of use. We also take into account the user reviews and ratings that each benefit eyeliner has received. We then test each product ourselves to compare our results with what we have read. This helps us gain a better understanding of how well the benefit eyeliner performs in real life applications.

Finally, we consult experts in the industry and ask their opinions on which benefit eyeliner they feel is best suited for your need and why. By taking all of these factors into account, we are able to make an informed decision on which benefit eyeliner is best for your needs. We always strive to provide you with the most comprehensive and unbiased information so that you can make the right choice when it comes to finding the best benefit eyeliner for your needs.

We also consider pricing when making our recommendations, as well as customer service and benefit eyeliner warranties when available. Our goal is to always provide our customers with the best benefit eyeliner at the most affordable prices. Thank you for taking the time to learn about how we test benefit eyeliner and make our selection process. We hope you found it helpful.

Best Benefit Eyeliner Buying Guide

Buying the right benefit eyeliner can be a difficult decision, especially when there are so many options available. A great way to make sure you’re getting the best value for your money is to consult a buying guide. By following a few simple steps, you can ensure that you make an informed decision about what benefit eyeliner is right for you and your budget.

First, do your research. Look at reviews from other customers and compare benefit eyeliner to find the one that best fits your needs. Make sure to read up on any warranties or guarantees offered by the benefit eyeliner manufacturers as well. This will help you make sure you know what kind of service and support is available should something go wrong with your purchase.

Second, consider your budget. Make sure to factor in any additional costs associated with the benefit eyeliner you’re considering. These could include shipping, taxes, or installation fees. If these are too high for your budget, you may want to look into another option.

Third, read up on return policies and customer service options. You want to make sure that you can return the benefit eyeliner if it doesn’t meet your expectations or if something goes wrong with it. Ask yourself if you’re comfortable dealing with customer service representatives of the company you are buying from and whether or not they offer any additional support for their products.

Finally, consider how long the benefit eyeliner has been available on the market. This will give you an indication of how reliable it is and whether or not it has been tested and approved by other customers. It will also help you make sure that the benefit eyeliner won’t be outdated in a few months’ time.

By following these steps, you can ensure that you get the best value for your money when buying a benefit eyeliner. The key is to do your research and make sure that you understand the company, benefit eyeliner, and policy before making a purchase. Good luck!

Question Need To Know Before Buying A Benefit Eyeliner

Before buying a benefit eyeliner, it’s important to ask yourself some key questions:

  • What are the ingredients?
  • Is this benefit eyeliner ethically made?
  • How is this benefit eyeliner tested on animals?
  • Will this benefit eyeliner have a negative impact on the environment?
  • Does this benefit eyeliner expire soon?
  • Is this a sustainable benefit eyeliner?
  • What is the return policy?
  • Is this benefit eyeliner within my budget?
  • Are there any additional fees or hidden costs associated with this benefit eyeliner?
  • Can I get a warranty on this benefit eyeliner?
  • Do I need any additional accessories for this benefit eyeliner to work properly?
  • Who can provide me with support if I have questions or issues with the benefit eyeliner

Ways to Order Benefit Eyeliner Smartly From E-Commerce Websites

When ordering benefit eyeliner from e-commerce websites, it is important to take the necessary steps to ensure your purchase goes smoothly. Following these tips can help you order smartly and prevent any major issues:

First, be sure to read customer reviews for the benefit eyeliner you’re interested in. This can provide valuable insight into what other customers thought of the benefit eyeliner, which can help you decide if it’s worth purchasing or not. Additionally, check for any special offers or discounts on the benefit eyeliner that could save you money.

Once you have decided to make your purchase benefit eyeliner, be sure to double-check all information provided in the ordering process such as shipping address, payment method, and any coupons or promotional codes. Making sure all this information is correct will help ensure a smooth purchase.

Finally, keep an eye out for your order confirmation email and tracking number to track the progress of your package. This will help you stay up to date on when your product should arrive and help you resolve any potential issues that may arise.

By following these tips, you can make sure your purchase benefit eyeliner from an e-commerce website goes as smoothly as possible. With the right preparation and knowledge, you can save time and money while getting the benefit eyeliner you need quickly and safely.


What Is The Best Benefit Eyeliner?

The best benefit eyeliner depends on a variety of factors, including budget, individual needs, and desired features. To help determine the best benefit eyeliner for you, our team of experts is available to help guide you through the selection process.

What Is Different Between A Expensive Vs A cheap Benefit Eyeliner?

There are a few key factors that differentiate expensive and cheap benefit eyeliner. Expensive benefit eyeliner tends to be made with higher quality materials and have better construction. They also often come with more features, making them more versatile. Cheap benefit eyeliner, on the other hand, are typically made with lower quality materials and have fewer features. This makes them less durable and less versatile. Additionally, cheap products often don’t last as long as expensive ones.

How Do I Choose The Right Benefit Eyeliner For Me?

The best way to determine which benefit eyeliner is right for you is to consider your budget, individual needs, and desired features. Our team of experts can help guide you through this process to ensure that you get the perfect benefit eyeliner for your needs.

What Should I Know Before Buying A Benefit Eyeliner?

Before buying a benefit eyeliner, it is important to take into consideration a few key factors. First and foremost, consider your budget and individual needs. Ask yourself if the benefit eyeliner you are considering is within your price range and meets your desired functionality. It is also essential to think about the features of the benefit eyeliner, such as durability, versatility, and quality. Finally, it is important to read reviews and do your research to make sure you are getting the best value for your money.

Why Do We Need To Check The Benefit Eyeliner Before Buying?

It is essential to check the benefit eyeliner before buying in order to make sure that it aligns with your individual needs and budget. With the immense variety of benefit eyeliner available, it can be difficult to determine which one is best for you. Checking the benefit eyeliner beforehand allows you to assess its features and quality, as well as read reviews from other customers. This helps to ensure that you are getting the best value for your money.

What Type Of Warranty And Guarantees Can I Expect?

The warranty and guarantees offered vary depending on the benefit eyeliner. Generally speaking, most products offer a certain amount of protection against manufacturing defects or damages. Additionally, some companies may offer additional guarantees, such as a satisfaction guarantee or a money-back guarantee. It is important to read the warranty and guarantee information of a benefit eyeliner before making a purchase in order to ensure that you are getting the protection you need.

Conclusion about Benefit Eyeliner

The best benefit eyeliner is the one that meets the needs of the customer. The benefit eyeliner should be easy to use, meet all of the customer’s requirements, and be available at a fair price. If you can find a benefit eyeliner that meets these criteria, you’re likely to have a satisfied customer who will return for future purchases.

Leave a Comment